You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience.

print article Print article

Debatable point: Buenos Aries Art Museum by Prechteck.

Images: Prechteck

The competition proposal by Prechteck for Buenos Aries' new art museum is bold and dramatic. But it has also run into controversy from some quarters for its arguably weak site response.

The debate raises an interesting question that is being played-out in many countries, particularly where there is rapid development occurring.

What extent is civic architecture obliged to respond to the site context as the hierarchically superior consideration?

Considering Greek classical architectural hierarchy: if the matrix of buildings responds or defers to the parti, does the parti need necessarily defer to its site? The Greeks of course thought it did, the Romans far less so, appearing to consider their civic buildings more as expressions of power rather than taste. The early, classically trained Modernists, thought genius loci important, but as that movement progressed, this viewpoint appeared to diminish, particularly as architectural education itself changed.

In recent years, there has arguably been a resurgence in classical values in urban design. But with emerging economic powers keen to announce their presence on the world stage, will the politicians that commission those important civic buildings ever be able to resist the attraction of stunning if brash architecture?

Alternatively is this debate just the last bastion of architectural snobbery for declining economic and cultural powers?

Facade detail.

Facade detail.

Interior view of facade

Interior of a gallery.

View of models

Circulation diagrams.

Explanation of form.

Plans

Section.

Internal perspective.

 

Tags:
Current magazine
DETAIL 6/2020
DETAIL 6/2020

Modular prefabricated

See magazine
Product teaser
Advertisement

ARCHITECTURE & DESIGN

Detail Newsletter

We will keep you informed about international projects, news on architectural and design topics, research and current events in our newsletter.