You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience.

print article Print article

And thoughts remain free: Creativity versus BIM?

Creativity finds a valve, regardless of the means used for its visualization. This "creative law" has a direct influence on the use of the BIM planning method, as many architects and engineers associate BIM with a loss of creative power in design and planning. However, BIM is a useful tool that, when used correctly, creates more freedom for creative work. 
Graphisoft, the manufacturer of the BIM planning software Archicad, asked four architects about their experiences with the digital planning method. They paint a differentiated picture in which BIM in no way inhibits good architecture and creativity. 
Recognising the value of one's own work.
The viewpoint of Titus Bernhard (Titus Bernhard Architekten) is clear: "BIM and creativity are not mutually exclusive. On the contrary, I see BIM as a tool for structuring a project, for simplifying handling with the participants in the planning process, and for facilitating handling with the client. Two levels meet: The design level, which has to do with the talent and the understanding of the architect, and the second level, which is the structuring of the project, its handling, and the possibility of generating efficiency with BIM. In the best-case scenario, this means greater efficiency and simple processing, and that we as a result have more time for the design work."
In the beginning there is the vision. BIM doesn't change this.
Hans-Martin Renn (Renn Architekten) also recognises a technological component: "In the beginning there is the vision. BIM doesn't change this. This vision needs to be filled and underpinned. Building products, technology, and the demands placed on architects have all changed. The whole structure is new. It's great when you can see where the difficulties lie as early as the planning stage and not just on the construction site. BIM is a method that supports creativity – technologically." 
Understanding the processes and mastering the tools.
But why are many architects reluctant to introduce BIM despite the positive feedback? Torben Wadlinger (Graf + Partner Architekten) primarily blames the ignorance concerning work processes for this: "Many people miss the point: BIM and design are two separate things. If I design in the traditional way, for example with my 6B pencil, then this sketch is subsequently transformed into a spatial structure. And if a pencil sketch can be structurally realised in this way, then I can plan and build it virtually too. If I'm unable to do so, I simply haven't mastered my BIM tool. A lot of colleagues say to me: 'BIM robs architects of their creativity.' That, however, is what those who don't work with the tool say."
BIM is the tool in the planning process. The architecture is the result. 
Florian Kraft's office (Stefan Forster Architekten) also works with BIM: "The method and its influence on architects' creativity are hotly debated here in Frankfurt. Recently I was at an event and people were saying: 'For heaven's sake, what is this new BIM thing?' 25 years ago, when CAD was introduced into offices, people reacted in the exact same way, and were wondering whether CAD would limit creativity. It did not. I'm a trained carpenter. In the past, whenever I got hold of a new tool, I used to think: 'What can I do with this, and how will it allow me to work more effectively and better?' It's the same with BIM. As architects, it is our tool."

Graphisoft, Digitales Planen, BIM, Kreativität

Photos: Renn Architekten, Fischen/Allgäu

Hans-Martin Renn: "In the beginning there is the vision, which needs to be technologically underpinned." The ski jump he planned for Oberstdorf combines the partial planning of statics, the steel construction (clearly visible in the image on the right) and the design idea in the BIM overall model. As a result, the method underpins both the constructive and design quality. Both visualizations are generated directly from ARCHICAD.
Graphisoft, Digitales Planen, BIM, Kreativität

Photo left: Eren Karaman, Sonthofen/Sportstätten Oberstdorf; Photo right: Stefan Betz, Oberstdorf/Sportstätten Oberstdorf

Planning and reality lie close together: The Heini Klopfer Ski Jump Oberstdorf has been planned with BIM.
Graphisoft, Digitales Planen, BIM, Kreativität

Photos: Lisa Farkas, Frankfurt/Main

Stefan Forster Architekten from Frankfurt work consistently with the BIM method throughout all work phases. Florian Kraft, one of the office partners and very familiar with the method, says: "BIM is a tool for architects that, rather than restricting ideas and creativity, instead promotes them." Left photo: the "Oskar Residence" residential development, directly on the banks of the river Main in Frankfurt. Right photo: the "Riedberg 04" housing estate. 106 apartments were built here in Frankfurt's Riedberg district.
Current magazine
DETAIL 7+8/2021

Small Houses

See magazine
Product teaser


Detail Newsletter

We will keep you informed about international projects, news on architectural and design topics, research and current events in our newsletter.